I tried the disputed 75¢ slices of the pizza war today for lunch. I have to say, 75¢ is novel, but neither tops my personal favorite cheap slice at 99¢ Fresh Pizza on Lexington and 43rd.
One of the most important factors to trying cheap pizza is going when it is really busy so as to not get a solidified grease chewy reheated slice. The 2 Bros. was super packed and the pizza was pretty fresh. The Bombay Fast Food was not as packed and not as exciting. Their pizza dough was bland.
My snap judgement is that 2 Bros. is better. The Bombay Fast Food slice was fine and given different circumstances I would totally have it again. But since there is a better slice next door, I don’t think I would go there again. Sorry bros.